The Role of Community Science in Addressing Policy Change: A Critical Review of Air Pollution Literature

Peer Reviewed
31 March 2025

Current Environmental Health Reports

Emilia Oscilowicz, Guadalupe A. Solís, Laura Martinez, Jeremy Németh, Gregory L. Simon, Carrie Makarewicz, Katherine L. Dickinson, Lisa M. Mckenzie, Jean Scandlyn, Paulina Erices-Ocampo, Patrick L. Kinney, Priyanka DeSouza

Abstract

Background Community air pollution science serves as a vital tool in public health and urban planning, enabling communities to advocate for policy changes that improve public health outcomes. Despite its potential, there is a noticeable gap in translating research findings into policy actions.

Objectives This review aims to assess the focus of studies on community air pollution science published between 1990-2023 and identify the extent to which these studies address the research-to-policy gap.

Methods We conducted a comprehensive review of 131 studies that utilize low-cost sensors for monitoring air pollution. The review specifically looked for how these studies contribute to bridging the research-to-policy gap.

Results Our findings indicate a significant emphasis on evaluating the performance of low-cost sensors, with 90% of the studies centered on this aspect. Only 10% of the studies explicitly aimed at addressing the research-to-policy gap. Among these, 10 studies employed distinct theories of change to tackle this issue effectively.

Conclusion There is a critical need for a paradigm shift in community science research to enhance the impact of scientific findings on policy-making. This shift should include strategies such as equitable sensor distribution, a broader focus on regions in the Global South, and proactive engagement with policymakers from the early stages of research.

Recommendations Future research should prioritize closing the research-to-policy gap by incorporating these strategies to ensure that community air pollution science fully realizes its potential in shaping public health policies.

Files and links

Publication reference
Oscilowicz, E., Solís, G. A., Martinez, L., Németh, J., Simon, G. L., Makarewicz, C., Dickinson, K. L., Mckenzie, L. M., Scandlyn, J., Erices-Ocampo, P., Kinney, P. L., & DeSouza, P. (2025). The Role of Community Science in Addressing Policy Change: A Critical Review of Air Pollution Literature. Current Environmental Health Reports, 12(1). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40572-025-00483-w
Publication | 17 September 2025