Don’t leave your kid unattended? Sex differences in children’s competitiveness in presence of their guardian.

Peer Reviewed
1 October 2024

Silvia Ortiz-Merchán, María José Lee-Ocampo, Sebastián Cuéllar-Harker, Maria Fernanda Bolívar, Diana Barriga, David Hernández, Alexander Villasmil, César Mantilla

Abstract

In the growing literature connecting parents-child economic decision-making, it remains unclear whether children’s competitive performance is affected by their guardian’s presence. We conducted a field experiment in which over 150 children were assigned to one of three tasks (i.e., trivia, a speed stacking game, or jumping a rope) and then chose to compete. Simultaneously, we elicited the guardians’ beliefs about their child’s willingness to compete in the three tasks and their expected performance. We employed a randomized encouragement design, asking guardians to remain close and support their child during the task or to remain distant. We find a positive correlation between the guardians’ presence and better performance in the speed stacking game (but not in the other tasks). Mothers’ beliefs about competitive behavior and performance across tasks are more correlated than fathers’ beliefs. Mixed-sex pairs (i.e., girls with a male guardian and boys with a female guardian) are more likely to compete than same-sex pairs.

Topics
EfD Authors

Files and links

Country
Sustainable Development Goals
Publication reference
Ortiz-Merchán, S., Lee-Ocampo, M. J., Cuéllar-Harker, S., Bolívar, M. F., Barriga, D., Hernández, D., Villasmil, A., & Mantilla, C. (2024). Don’t leave your kid unattended? Sex differences in children’s competitiveness in presence of their guardian. Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics, 112, 102254. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socec.2024.102254
Publication | 8 July 2024