central america eeu sweden | Parks & Wildlife Policy design

Paying the Price of Sweetening Your Donation: Evidence from a Natural Field Experiment

Using a natural field experiment in a recreational site, a public good almost fully dependent on voluntary donations, the authors explored the crowding-out effect of gift rewards. First, they investigated whether receiving a map in appreciation of a donation crowded out prosocial behavior and found no significant effect of giving the map. Second, they explored the effect of adding the map to a treatment designed to increase donations. Interestingly, when the gift was combined with their attempt to trigger reputational and self image motives, the probability of donating decreased significantly, compared to the social reference treatment alone.

In this paper, the authors show how a treatment intended to trigger higher donations by appealing to reputational motives is crowded out by extrinsic incentives. Even when applied in isolation, a gift in appreciation of prosocial behavior is not a suitable motivation for increasing donations. In both these cases, if we take into account the cost of the map, we end up with a vertical or negatively sloped supply curve, as predicted in Bénabou and Tirol’s (2006) model: the free map results in a loss to the park. Our results contradict Falk (2007) who found a significant effect of gift giving. One explanation for this difference could be that motivational crowding out is larger when the intentions of gift giving are more clearly attributable to a particular “culprit” (i.e., the national park authorities), which is clearer in our paper, compared to Falk (2007).

 

EfD Authors

Keywords

Files

Centers

  • central america
  • eeu sweden

Type of publication

  • EfD Discussion paper

Reference

Alpízar, Francisco and Peter Martinsson (2010), “Paying the Price of Sweetening Your Donation Evidence from a Natural Field Experiment”,EfD Discussion Paper 10-06, Environment for Development Initiative and Resources for the Future, Washington DC, February 2010.

Comments

Publications

EfD Newsletter

Subscribe to our Newsletter service

Join or share



Follow EfD on Twitter
Join EfD on LinkedInJoin EfD on LinkedIn

Project info

What affect voluntary contributions to national parks? A field study in Cahuita National Park

The project investigates the determinants of contributions (compulsory and voluntary) to national [cont...]

See Also

Metodología para la estimación de tarifas para los servicios no esenciales a concesionar dentro de [...]

Resultados de estudio económico y línea base de las actividades de los funcionarios en el Parque [cont...]

Are experienced people affected by a pre-set default option—Results from a field experiment

The objective of the present paper is to investigate the robustness of the well-known result that [cont...]