central america eeu sweden | Behavior ec. Parks & Wildlife

Does context matter more for hypothetical than for actual contributions? Evidence from a natural field experiment

We investigate the importance of the social context for people’s voluntary contributions to a national park in Costa Rica, using a natural field experiment.

IMG_3348.JPG


This present paper presents results of a natural field experiment – using the terminology of Harrison and List (2004) – in Costa Rica, where we investigate the importance of (1) anonymity with respect to the solicitor and (2) information about the contributions of others. In particular, we quantify and compare these effects for two samples: one based on hypothetical contributions and one on actual contributions. Both the degree of anonymity and provided information about the contributions of others influence subject contributions in the hypothesized direction. We do find a substantial hypothetical bias with regard to the amount contributed. However, the influence of the social contexts is about the same when the subjects make actual monetary contributions as when they state their hypothetical contributions. Our results have important implications for validity testing of stated preference methods: a comparison between hypothetical and actual behavior should be done for a given social context.

EfD Authors

Keywords

Files

Centers

  • central america
  • eeu sweden

Type of publication

  • Peer reviewed

Reference

Alpízar, F., F. Carlsson, and O. Johansson-Stenman. 2007. "Does context matter more for hypothetical than for actual contributions? Evidence from a natural field experiment". Experimental Economics, forthcoming.

Publications

See Also

It is Better to Be the Head of a Chicken than the Tail of a Phoenix? A Study of Concern for [...]

The authors discuss a survey-experiment method, measuring to what extent poor Chinese farmers care [cont...]

‘Contribute! You can make a difference!’

A nature field experiment and a choice experiment of the payment system of voluntary contribution. [cont...]